Where it differs: On paper it lists coumarin that the original does not, and does not list the original's white bergamot or ginger.
Smells like Creed Virgin Island Water. USD 49 instead of 490
4 bottles the community rates close to Virgin Island Water, 90 percent cheaper at the top, with the one thing each does differently. citrus, boozy, floral, unisex.
Creed Virgin Island Water, USD 490
Main accords
The chart every fragrance forum reads. Longest bar, strongest accord.
Notes
Black means ALT Fragrances Caribbean Water shares the note.
Top
- Lime
- Sicilian Mandarin
- White Bergamot
- Coconut
Heart
- Hibiscus
- Indian Jasmine
- Ylang-Ylang
- Ginger
Base
- Musk
- Sugar Cane
- White Rum
The 4 worth trying, ranked
Similarity is the owners' vote plus the note overlap. Price is a typical US bottle price when the house publishes one. Bars are each match's own accords.
Where it differs: No published difference found yet; compare opening and longevity on skin.
Where it differs: On paper it lists tropical fruits and spices that the original does not, and does not list the original's sicilian mandarin or white bergamot.
Where it differs: On paper it lists bergamot and tropical fruits that the original does not, and does not list the original's sicilian mandarin or white bergamot.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Similarity figures come from owner ratings and published notes, never from a lab, and no bottle here is a copy of another. Brand names appear only to say what a scent is similar to.
Side by side, the way people actually decide
Two bottles, two prices, one honest sentence. Every match on the site has this card.
Read about ALT Fragrances Caribbean WaterCreed Virgin Island Water
USD 490, 100 ml
ALT Fragrances Caribbean Water
USD 49, 60 ml
86 similar. On paper it lists coumarin that the original does not, and does not list the original's white bergamot or ginger, 90 percent less.